Friday, March 8, 2013

The Gift of Insecurity

The column below appeared in the December, 2010 issue of the Sturbridge Times Magazine.


November saw much discussion in the media about the vast resources allocated to insure the president’s safe trip to India.  There was some disagreement about the number of naval vessels that would accompany him.  Even the lesser number than originally quoted would have been enough to destroy all but the world’s largest navies.  To insure a peaceful sleep, it sounded as if every hotel room in Mumbai was to be reserved, just in case.
The security mania did not start with the incumbent and Mumbai does have an image problem around safety after the 2008 siege.  Still, the recent foreign tour highlights what to some, namely me, might seem a problem.
An article, Lunch With George, written by the publisher and editor of this publication has been on my mind since it appeared in the August of 2008 issue.  Paul Carr wrote about an afternoon spent in the near company of George Bush the elder.   I did not think his portrayal of the ex president to be unsympathetic, but neither was it fawning.  It was a day in the life of a man who had had his day in the sun.  The 41st president was just enjoying post celebrity mode.
What I took away from Paul’s article was not about the man being out and noticed by the public.  What caught my eye were the security arrangements.  The man had been out of office over a decade and a half.  The only person known to have it in for him lethally went to the gallows.  Yet, he will be accompanied by men described in the article as “behemoths” as long as he lives.  Every president will have this protection for life.
Contrast this with the current state of travel for an American citizen.  He or she may have to go through a machine that will leave nothing about their anatomy to speculation.  If they opt out of the electronic pat down, the physical one is more demeaning.
So are we being paranoid?  Let’s do the math. It has been reported that we have passed the million mark on our national No Fly List. Breaking down the numbers, on 911 it was a team of 19 men who executed the plan. Assume that there were six liaison, handlers and other staff. That makes up a crew of 25. That means a possible 40,000 terror teams whose potential members we know about, but just won’t let fly. I may never come out from under my bed.
It seems we are going to the National Security State with us all on lockdown. A few years ago a car veered off our street. An officer responded and did a normal investigation. It was a little strange that he was wearing a SWAT uniform. At our town meeting, the department requested and was voted the police version of the M-16. There is almost never an arrest here. It is that boring aspect of the town that we love. Yet, our town dads and moms can be easily stampeded into paranoia.
Never mind that statistics show that we are pretty safe. We are still told that without a constant effort we will be at the mercy of the terrorists. With what we are paying for our Department of Homeland Security, we should not have a care in the world.
There is reason for a climate of fear. We are in danger.  It’s just not the danger being sold. When we screw our courage to the sticking point and finally get in the car to get a slurpie down at a convenience store, we have a good chance of becoming a casualty. Not from Abdul the Jihadi, but from another driver crashing into us. Go and poll undertakers in your region about how many kids they’ve buried due to a drowning in the family pool.  Ask them how many local terrorists have caused any funerals.
So we are heading toward more and more control. We need “Real Id” to make us feel better. In a scene from the movie The Hunt for Red October, Sam Neill's character is talking with Sean Connery's.  Neill talks about how he is going to travel from state to state in his recreational vehicle when he becomes an American. At one point he says, "No papers?" and Connery affirms, "No Papers." It is the difference between a free and unfree country. What will we say when we have to hear, “Your papers, please.”
I expect to be accused  of Lèse majesté for the suggestion I intend to make, but so be it.  It is time to take away the Secret Service protection of presidents and candidates and other officials and people of importance. Now, before giving vent to paroxysms of rage, think about it. A vast sum of money is spent to protect him and a fortune is spent to watch you in your own name. There is no incentive to change the system.
I have no desire to see anyone in government be the victim of any violence. Let me not mince words. I wish it to happen to my lumpen countrymen far less. We should all have the same level of protection or the same risk.
The desire to protect the president is understandable. There have been a number of assassination attempts since JFK. Like all my contemporaries, I remember my circumstances that day. The funeral was spectacle, but it was heart wrenching no less for that.
Since then we’ve had the King shooting, the attempt on Reagan’s life. The multiple bizarre attempts on Ford didn’t help. Remember Arthur Lee Bremer?  We started getting paranoid even about fringe candidates.
That all is true, but the thing about the presidency is there is never a dearth of ambitious men (and some women) who seek it. It is a pinnacle of success. It is also a position of leadership and therefore should not be without risk. Serious risk. Though not a betting man, I would be happy to wager that even without the coterie of guards we now provide, there would still be a surfeit of aspirants.
So how would this reform help anything? If the president cannot have a protecting force for himself, he may be cognizant of a shared risk. Our protection should be his protection and his should be ours. It is theory we should be willing to test.
Who knows, we could get back to a real human presidency. Harry Truman used to walk down to the drugstore by himself in the morning to get the paper. That may never happen, but if the president doesn’t want to go out without a helicopter hovering overhead, he can subscribe.
Oh well, things won’t change.  I should just seek a sinecure that leads to the need for protection. I want three security personnel and a driver on the federal dime. Would be willing to trade one of the agents for a masseuse.



Thursday, March 7, 2013

Veritas in Sturbridge:a truly fine dining experience

UPDATE: Sadly Veritas has closed.

Below is my review of the Sturbridge restaurant, Veritas that appeared in the October, 2012 Sturbridge Times Magazine.

Dining Out

Veritas in Sturbridge: a truly fine dining experience


-->
Since the dawn of humanity, people have been searching for truth.  Finally, we can stop, at least in Sturbridge.  The lovely building at 420 Main Street now is home to Veritas, Latin for truth. 
You will not find philosophers debating what is the good.  Instead, diners seeking victuals and staff preparing and presenting them are there.   When we entered we were cordially greeted and taken into the colonial dining room.
Our waiter, Rick came by to ask if we had a drink order.  We told him that we would choose a wine with the dinner, but would like the fried calamari appetizer.  Rick took the order but quickly returned with a breadbasket.  A buttery sweet potato spread came with the bread.  It seems sweet potato is in everything these days, which is not something to complain about.
The calamari came in due course, served with feta, capers and field greens with an aioli sauce.   It was crunchy and gone quickly.
We ordered dinner when the appetizer arrived, and it came soon after we had finished the calamari. 
My choice was the sauerbraten, a German pot roast.  The menu described it as being made Rupprecht’s way.  Rupprecht’s way is a well-flavored serving of beef.  It was accompanied by a sweet and sour sauce and spaetzle.  I like spaetzle, a soft noodle and the sauce was nice.  Better was the wonderful red cabbage that completed the plate.
Bríd, my daughter, ordered the ahi tuna steak. It was large and cooked medium rare. The noodles, seaweed salad, and ceviche on the side were all full flavor and fun additions

The hit of the afternoon however was the Salmon Oscar my wife ordered.  The salmon itself was pan seared and had a delicate flavor and tenderness.  The asparagus in béarnaise sauce with basil garnish was lovely and of course, who does not love garlic mashed potatoes.
My wife’s desert was the Crème Suchard, which is a light chocolate mousse, whimsically called Moose on the menu.  She described it as delightful.  It is composed of chocolate, whipped cream and cookies and served in a martini glass.
My key lime pie came with pineapple, mango coulis, a cool dish on a warm early evening.
Bríd ordered the bread pudding. She described it as tender, flavorful, and large. Also the brandy sauce was “killer.”

As you approach the restaurant at the front door, there is a sign with the legend, In Vino Veritas.  This is a hint as to the truth Kelly and Kurt Soukup were looking for.  The phrase translates as “In wine, truth.”  It means after enough wine, one cannot lie.  Kelly and Kurt were looking for truth in good wine for a wine bar they contemplated opening in Hartford.  That did not happen, but they loved the name and would use it twice.
What is immediately evident about the couple is they love the restaurant business.  Kurt started at 14 years of age doing dishes at the old Lakehouse in Wilbraham.  His true education began at the Student Prince, a Springfield Institution.  Under the tutelage of Chef Rupprecht he learned everything from butchering to the formal tableside service.
Kelly started waitressing 14 years ago.  Obviously, she got along with Kurt and now gets to run the front of the operation.  This is not the first Veritas.  On the American Caribbean island of Vieques, they operated an open-air restaurant for three years.  They still own the home they built there.
The Soukups came back to Massachusetts because of family.  It can’t be the weather.  Fortunately they found 420 Main Street and signed a lease.  They have only praise for the landlords at the 420 complex who have been there for them.
Everything is made on the property, including catsup and pickles.  They do their best to source locally.  Their goal is to be consumer friendly and economy friendly given the current financial environment. 
The happy hour menu is a budget bill of fare.  Especially so is the build your own burger option.  The toppings list is exhaustive.  Mondays is burger and beer night, a pint of the beer of the month and a 9oz burger is $11.

We also sampled the Stone Pie.  No, it is not a pie made of stone, but a pizza made in a stone oven.  We have good pizza in Sturbridge, but the stone pie is New Haven style, which is popular in the lower Nutmeg State.  New Haven style pizza in Sturbridge is news.  We sampled the Giardino, a vegetable topped thin crust pie.   There is a Wednesday deal of $30 for a pizza and bottle of wine from the Forever $21 wine list.

On Sunday nights, Prime Rib is on special.

The interior of the dining rooms is in an appealing colonial décor.  The bar upstairs is a cozy room.  Kurt’s mom made all the drapes and his dad framed the prints.  Veritas is a welcome addition to the Sturbridge restaurant lineup.

You can read more about Veritas at http://veritasma.com/.



Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Tax The Poor

Below is my column from the February 1, 2013 issue of the Sturbridge Times Magazine.  I take some vindication from the linked Christian Science Monitor article titled, New Tax Law will increase the burden on the poor. 

Anyway, the article is below.  Enjoy if you can.

-->
The fiscal cliff has come and gone and no doubt will come again.  As always, a deal was done, and the figurative can was kicked down the road.
A constant drumbeat during the run-up to the agreement was that if the exchequer could just put its hands in the pockets of the rich, why nirvana would ensue.  To cliché it, the tax the rich meme went viral.
I’m from a working class family and as resentful of my betters as the next guy.  The pitchfork is by the door and ready at a moments notice to storm the Bastille with me, at least rhetorically.
Certain segments of the wealthy should be fair game.  The ongoing crisis that began in 2008 had its origin in large banking institutions that are “Too Big To Fail” otherwise known as TBTF.  What that means is, as is said, that if they are allowed to sink, they crash civilization. 
In the recent presidential election, neither candidate addressed the too big to fail issue.  The incumbent never said that he had been working on the problem and the solution was in hand, because he hadn’t.  The challenger never suggested it would be a priority of his administration because he would have gargled razor blades rather than touch it had the votes had been counted in his favor.
We had a measure in place that kept the banks from getting TBTF.  It was called Glass-Steagall.  The Glass-Steagall Act of 1933, passed in a previous era of economic turmoil, prohibited Commercial Banks from engaging in the investment business.  What the act meant was succinctly put by economist and author of the book, Currency Wars.  James Rickards.  Rickards wrote on August 27, 2012 for US News and World Report, that under Glass-Steagall, “Banks would be allowed to take deposits and make loans.  Brokers would be allowed to underwrite and sell securities.  But no firm could do both due to conflicts of interest and risks to insured deposits.  From 1933 to 1999, there were very few large bank failures and no financial panics comparable to the panic of 2008.  The law worked exactly as intended.”
If life was not horrible under Glass-Steagall, why was it thrown overboard?  This can be explained by the nature of our party structure.  An anonymous Republican congressional staffer is credited with saying, “In America we have a two-party system.  There is the stupid party, and the evil party.  I am proud to be a member of the stupid party” The man then said, “Periodically, the two parties get together and do something that is both stupid and evil.  This is called bipartisanship.” 
Deep-sixing Glass-Steagall was bipartisanship at its most stupidly evil.  The people had not risen up and called for repeal.  Almost none of them had ever heard of it.  That’s what happens in a nation with a surfeit of laws.  No, it was the world of finance that used their influence to get what they wanted.  When they had sucked as much as they could out of the system, and it all started to go south, they went crying to the government for succor.  The bankers were all for profits staying privatized, but supported a healthy socialism when it came to losses.
So, a class of people did some looting on a vast scale and got away with it.  The cry has gone up, “Make them pay their fair share.”  To paraphrase the old western horse operas, “Taxing is too good for them.”  Unfortunately, they had gamed the system so that apparently the law, if not the force, is with them.  Of course, The SEC and the Department of Justice have been desultory at best in pursuing the wrongdoers.   There have been a few wrist slaps to pretend action, but nothing substantial.  We can’t even sentence them to having to listen non-stop to ABBA piped into jail cells for a few hours.  Okay, that is going overboard.
Taxing a class sounds like a fantastic idea.  Not all the rich were bankers and many provide honest employment for their fellow citizens.  Still, there is an argument that adjusting the tax rates upwards is a good thing.  The problem is, it is no panacea.  Most economists have admitted it can’t work magic. 
Taxing the rich inevitably reaches down into the pockets of the middle-class.  Don’t think so?  I have three letters for you, AMT.  They stand for Alternative Minimum Tax.  I don’t remember if it was Chet Huntley or John Chancellor or another newsreader in the 60s intoning in a serious talking head voice about an injustice.  The evil rich were getting away with murder.
By investing in municipal bonds, wealthy members of society were able to avoid federal taxes on the interest.  In doing this, they received a lower interest rate allowing governmental units to finance schools or bridges or other projects.  That did not matter.  Something had to be done.
What was done was the Alternative Minimum Tax.  In the early 1990s, the law was changed so the AMT could also tax people with lower incomes.  Our compassionate solons, troubled by the injustice, yearly “patch” it so most, but not all, of the middle class escapes.  Nothing permanent is ever done, though.
Adjusting the tax on the rich may raise a few dollars and make us feel good, but won’t solve the problem.  Taxing the middle-class other than the status quo is considered bad form.  What’s left?  Why of course, doing what has been done most consistently throughout history, taxing the poor. 
Unconscionable you say.  Balderdash.  We already tax the poor horribly, and couch it in terms of doing it for their own good.  The cigarette tax falls disproportionately on the shoulders of folks in the lower income bracket.  I have never heard a non-smoking fellow citizen decry this as an injustice though it raises the price of a small pleasure several times.  Taxes on alcohol are not light, but see how far you get proposing an excise that triples the cost of single malt out of compassion for the health of the wealthy.
Throughout history societies sooner or later get around to taxing the poor.  This can be fraught with danger.  Take the French aristocracy who had their heads handed to them.  No, a federal tax on the downtrodden will have to be done shrewdly.
Fortunately, there is a way to do it that, if not loved, will be embraced with enthusiasm.  In this the states have shown the way.  Many of us have stood in line waiting to pay for gas or coffee at a convenience store.  Often there is someone ahead of us taking what seems years to make several choices.  To the more highly evolved, they are wasting time, but to that man or woman, it is a momentous choice.  With each new day, it is the most important decision of their life.  If their choice of scratch ticket or lottery numbers is correct, the drudge job they hate is history, at least till the money runs out.
As a math professor once said, “The lottery is a tax on people who can’t do math.”  It is the shrewdest form of impost ever devised.  Why should not the federals use it to solve our ongoing fiscal crises?  A nightly national Powerball drawing will beat even Dancing With The Stars’ ratings.
Ah well, this may take a while to come to pass.  There are a few tricks left like a trillion dollar platinum coin so why worry.  After all the Congress saw it’s duty, came together and raised taxes on the elite, and while you were feeling good on you too, Mr. and Mrs. Two Earner Family.
Yup. The two percent increase in payroll tax will affect you more than anything that might have been done to Warren Buffett
My countrymen and women, you were like marks for a three-card monte dealer.  While the barker kept yelling beat the rich, he took your money.
Bipartisanship, ya gotta love it.

Saturday, February 16, 2013

Our National Deficit


My  May, 2010 column from the Sturbridge Times Magazine and an observation on the Senate.
Our National Deficit
There was a recent video of a congressman that caused a lot of mirth all across the internet.  Representative Hank Johnson of Georgia was questioning the commander of the Pacific Fleet, Admiral Robert Willard. At one point, he inquired if there was any concern that the island of Guam could, due to overpopulation, “tip over and capsize.” In one of the most adroit displays of self-control, Admiral Willard completely retained his composure. On hearing Johnson, most normal folks would have said something like, “c’mon Hank, yer kiddin” after rolling on the floor. Nope, he wasn’t and the admiral knew it. Like any military bureaucrat, Willard has to worry about appropriations. Maybe Johnson was having some fun, but why take chances?
To be fair, the congressman is suffering from hepatitis C and this does affect judgment. Still, the lower house of our national legislature has not been known for a lack of interesting characters in its history.  Wilbur Mills would make the list. He served as Ways and Means chairman longer than anyone ever did. It is a position of immense power and in his tenure he had the respect of the congress. No one remembers that. As powerful as he was, he lived in relative obscurity until October 9, 1974. In the early hours of that fall morning, he was stopped by the police because his car lights were not on. No big thing, might have blown over except that someone ran from the car into the tidal basin.  It still might have gone away had it been, say, a doyenne of DC society. Unfortunately, it was a women whose professional name was Fanne Fox. She billed herself as the Argentine Bombshell. Her dancing was known for a progressive lack of clothing. Did ol Wilbur come to his senses?  Only if you call following her to Boston and climbing onto the stage at a burlesque theater sensible. Wilbur, who had studied constitutional law at Harvard, made Hank look like the soul of reason.
You probably think I am appalled by all of this. Not in the least. True, I don’t think the antics of the solons are in anyway positive, but that’s not the point. The framers of the constitution feared democracy, but they knew the average Joe must have a voice. The House of Representatives is that voice. When we elect its members, we are electing ourselves, and getting what we deserve, good and hard.
It is the Senate that bothers me. The framers of the constitution were trying to mimic a lot of what they rebelled against. A Senate was not meant to be democratic. The closest example the former colonists had was the British House of Lords. The lords did not have to pander for votes. Men who do not have to take into account public opinion should be more deliberative.
Supposedly, Washington told Jefferson that the Senate would be a cooling saucer against the passions of the House. The hereditary title business, however, was not going to fly. What to do?
The solution was to have the Senate selected by the state legislatures. Yeah, that worked. We all know that such bodies are composed only of persons of absolute rectitude. By the last quarter of the 19th century, numerous scandals had been exposed regarding corrupt elections of senators. David Graham Phillips, a muckraking journalist employed by William Randolph Hearst wrote a series of articles entitled The Treason of the Senate.  Sentiment for direct election of the upper house became a torrent.
Understandably, the senators were happy with the status quo. Only when the groundswell got so large that states were calling for a constitutional convention did the senate move an amendment. Even today, the thought of a constitutional convention scares sane people not to mention even some lunatics.
So what have we got for the great extension of the franchise? It takes oodles of cash to become a senator. Now, who will the victor in an election feel more beholden to, his constituents or the moneybags supporters? Of course, that begets election reform and when that is gamed, more election reform.
In the electronic age, elections are beauty contests. I met our senior senator during his first campaign. What I remember most about the encounter is not what he said, but his appearance. He was perfectly coifed and exquisitely dressed. I have never seen another man as well put together. Heck, I haven’t seen many women that well done up.
That senators are little more than reps with longer terms is probably not a good thing constitutionally. Ah, but the entertainment value is increased by an order of magnitude. Joe Biden has left the upper house, but all those gaffe skills he honed for years, he is putting to use as veep.  There is our own John Kerry being for a bill before being against, or was it the other way around?
Lest you think I only lampoon Dems, John McCain provided some mirth during the presidential debates. There is a Youtube mashup of the former candidate with Miss South Carolina. The beauty queen had been asked a question which she completely flubbed. When McCain was asked an economic question he dropped names and platitudes, but did not answer in any real sense. He was oblivious, and made the hapless lass from SC look like Cicero in comparison.
I don’t think a Lincoln and Douglas could run against each other today. They would not be photogenic enough and their logical presentation of issues would do them no good. I would love to say I could have followed their marathon debates, but I am a product of my times. I scare myself.

Saturday, January 19, 2013

A Capital Idea


Below is my column for the November, 2012 issue of the Sturbridge Times Magazine.   

Ah autumn in Nova Anglia.  It’s election time as presidential and congressional candidates tell us how they love us and wish to serve us, but not here.  No, they want to go to D.C. because life is good.
Washington is America’s richest city.  The capital and adjacent metro region beat out even Silicon Valley.   That should not be.  Silicon Valley is where the research is done for all the gadgets we cherish.  Washington only produces laws, lots of them.
Why should “crafting” legislation be such a big problem?  Because, they never stop.  According to the Wall Street Journal in 2011, there are so many laws, no one has any idea what the count is.  Ronald Gainer had the task at Justice to get the number.  He said, "You will have died and resurrected three times," and still not have the total.

So is this a problem?  In a democracy, certainly.  Don’t take my word for it.  The Roman orator, Tacitus, put it elegantly,

Corruptissima re publica plurimae leges

Roughly translated, it means a corrupt state has many laws.  It is understandable that a country with the oldest operating constitution will have passed innumerable bills.  That the actual number cannot be known is a scandal.


So what can be done to stop or at least arrest the pace of legislation? Fortunately, my fellow citizens, I’ve done the research and have come up with a solution.
 Several decades ago, upon separation from the serious work of defending my country, I embarked upon a trip across country with a friend in late spring.  We visited all the comrades who frivolously invited me to stop by once I got out.  Lacking the money to stay at motels when not sponging, we camped.  It was for the most part not unpleasant.

Then we came to Wyoming.  I have not spent a worse night. Getting up in the morning was hell.  We would have to leave the cold of the sleeping bags to dress and then go wash.  The late June day did warm up to just below tolerable. The Rockies had their own beauty but it was stark and bleak. Riding through was interesting to see but not enough to linger and there was no way a second night was going to be spent. 



My friends, the above-mentioned experience has moved me to propose to the nation that the capital must be moved to Wyoming.  The current seat of government is too nice. Our legislators need a harsh climate so few of them will wish to serve and those who do serve will not want to stay as long and pass laws.

Life will not be easy for publicity seeking solons up in the Cowboy State.  It is one thing to want to speak to the media and get face time when you are in a lovely tailored suit with perfectly coiffed hair.  Quite another when you are wearing a parka and a hat with ear flaps and your usually mellifluous voice is muffled because of the scarf covering your mouth.

It will be a more curmudgeonly type who seeks office under those conditions, and thus, more honest of speech.  Think about it, perky little Caitlin the correspondent asks Jake the retired math teacher with a face for radio but not the voice about the new education bill.  Jake gives the truth, "Listen girly, I'm not for giving one cent to the schools.  In my forty-five years in the classroom, I had about ten kids capable of doing real math, most of the rest wanted to sleep through class.  The school department mandated that I give the majority Cs when most of them deserved Ds."  She then asks, "Jake, don't you think your constituents will be offended by your comments." Jake, "If they don't like what I say, let ‘em vote for someone else. The food here is terrible, it's cold and I get stupid questions from reporters."



And speaking of cute little reporterettes and smooth, serious reporters, we would have less of them.  Duty in the new national capital would not be looked upon as the pinnacle of a career, but as punishment.  "Sorry folks, we won't be bringing you handsome, suave Brett up at the Senate building as he is too hungover again.  We do have some film from Lichtenstein History Month being celebrated at the Lichtenstein-American Community Center.”  Poor little Brett and Caitlin would be forever campaigning to be sent anywhere else other than, maybe, Pyongyang.

Now, I understand just physically moving the seat of government is not enough.  There will have to be limitations.  Generally speaking, I am not in favor of eminent domain, but in this case there is reason for an exception.  We find a town with a high school gym large enough to seat on those uncomfortable benches the House of Representatives.  The auditorium must be just big enough to accommodate the Senate. No more great architecture to inspire their imperial dreams.  If there is a medium size bank in town, that can serve as the President's office. A local district court should be all that is necessary for the Supremes (unfortunately, I don't mean the three chanteuses). 



Housing and building regulations will have to be strict.  We can have no vast mansions.  No, we shall build our masters what we do for the aging citizens of this republic.  They can live in senior citizen style housing equivalent to that which they subsidize across the country.  It will be Spartan, but if it is good enough for Grandma, it's good enough for John Boehner and Nancy Pelosi.  Anyway, they won't be spending much time there.  The most oft spoken word in our new capital will be adjournment. 



One other benefit to the big move will be we get to give back the District of Columbia to Virginia and Maryland.  Not that they might want it.  No more Marion Barrys.  No large federal metropolis to be supported by the rest of the country.  The Washington Post Style section with nothing to report.  Georgetown a ghost town. 



All right, I know my reverie can never come to pass.  I know that it is too much to hope that that place that started out as a swamp could return to being a swamp.  Well, I guess in a way it has always been a swamp.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Chinua Achebe’s memoir of war

This review was first published in the December, 2012 issue of the Sturbridge Times Magazine 


There Was A Country A Personal History Of Biafra
By Chinua Achebe
The Penguin Press, 2012
Hardcover, 258 pages
ISBN 978-1-59420-482-1
List: $27.95 Amazon: $16.63

In the late 1960s, for a very short span, there was an episode that gripped much of the world’s conscience.  A small bit of land holding millions of people was surrounded.  The populace was being starved to death.  By early 1970 the war that precipitated the catastrophe was all over.  Without any orders from an Orwellian ministry, for most of the world the struggle was consigned to the “Memory Hole.”
If one should ask today who remembers Biafra, it is doubtful one in ten living during the period could answer affirmatively.  Probably no one born after 1970 has ever heard of it.
I am part of the first TV generation and yield to no one in shortness of attention span.  Yet the war between the secessionist state of Biafra and Nigeria is etched in my mind.  How is it that an average American thinks often about what is now an obscure moment in time?
When the events in question were happening, I was a college student.  Well, in truth, not much of one.  I did my best not to over exert myself, but had a weakness for a good lecturer.  Justin Vojtek, professor of history, was an artist and in spite of the required effort I would be in his class.
The course would be a departure from the regular curriculum.  Colleges were beginning to take up African history.  The assigned reading included four novels by a man from the eastern region of Nigeria, Chinua Achebe.  He would be intimately involved in the events of the war.
Achebe was an Igbo.  Of all the various ethnic groups the British met as they patched together Nigeria, the Igbo were the most enthusiastic about taking up what the colonial regime offered.  This does not mean they forgot who and what they were, but they were changed by the experience.  The assigned novels reflected that change and its impact on his people.
Two of the novels, Things Fall Apart and Arrow of God concern themselves with how two important men are done in by geopolitical forces they do not understand.   Ezeulu is a priest in the traditional religion, an arrow of god.  He is steadfast in his service to his deity.  His interaction with the colonial administration upsets the schedule that will signal the harvest.  Despite his faithfulness, the people turn to Christianity, as it will offer a dispensation.
Things Fall Apart is the story of a strong man also done in by the arrival of the English.  Okonkwo is a man of status among his people.  He wishes to face the colonialists fairly and with honor.  The cold machine that is the new regime does not understand him and his people.  His dignity taken, he ends his life.
The third novel is the story of a young man of promise, Obi, who has obtained a smart university education and yet that does not prepare him for all the perils of the greater world.  Nor is he able to escape the problems of the old as he falls in love with an Osu or outcaste women.
The last book of the assigned quartet, A Man of the People, may be his most known work.  This is because of his famous “prediction” of the first coup d’état.  The book chronicles the corruption that led to the military takeover.  It did not foresee the breakup of the country.
There Was A Country is not only the story of Biafra, as one cannot tell that tale without consideration of all that preceded it.  He describes the colonial regime and the Igbo’s enthusiasm for learning and achievement.  Also, the independence struggle and his people’s part in it are chronicled.  The leadership of the men of his ethnic group was integral, if not the sine qua non.
Unfortunately, the Igbo success in the independence movement as well as business, education and the arts bred resentment.  The envy of the other ethnic groups led to pogroms and an exodus of his people from non–Igbo regions.  Achebe documents the resulting decline in relations leading to the declaration of a Biafran republic,
“And the war came,” as Lincoln put it in his second inaugural.  Whether or not he intended it, Achebe’s account has the flavor of horrible inevitability.  With international collusion, Nigeria had overwhelming force.  They surrounded Biafra and squeezed it to the end.  Yet, despite bombardment and blockade and starvation, the Igbo built a republic that functioned as complete state until the surrender.
Poignant is Achebe’s account of the life and death of Christopher Okigbo.  An accomplished poet, among other qualities, he set up a publishing house with Achebe.  When the war started, he enlisted and yet continued to work with the publishing business when time and duty permitted.  Made a major, Okigbo was always in the thick of battle.  Though not a callow youth when killed, neither was he an old man.  Still, Yeat’s line about the death of a young friend comes to mind, “What made us dream he could comb grey hair?”
The war ended, but the suffering continued for a time.  Eventually, the author rejoined the political process to no great success.  The final part of the book outlines the situation as it is.
As a reader, the conclusion I draw is my own.  The suppression of Biafra was one of the great crimes of the last century and that is saying something.  Nigeria and Africa are mired in corruption and the plethora of resources makes it worse.  Maybe the Igbo would not have made Port Harcourt a banking center or another Singapore.  Certainly, they would have managed the oil wealth more efficiently and with less corruption than the Nigerian state does now, to the benefit of the whole continent.
Achebe is a fine stylist and his treatment of the subject matter is valuable, yet I suspect this book will be soon forgotten by an incurious public.



.

Saturday, December 8, 2012

A scholar's take on Haiti's painful history

This review was first published in the March, 2012 issue of the Sturbridge Times Magazine.



Haiti The Aftershocks of History
By Laurent Dubois
Metropolitan Books Henry Holt and Company, 2012
Hardcover, 370 pages
ISBN-13: 978-0-8050-9335-3
List: $32.00 Amazon: $18.88

It would be one of the greatest acts of moral vandalism in history. A man who had defeated the Ancien Regime in the service of the French Republic and held a territory in its name would die of betrayal by the new regime in a mountain fortress.  In real terms he had betrayed the state, as he was governing in the interests of the people.  Rare as that is in a statesman.

              I saw the picture of that man in a resplendent uniform with coal black face on a library bookshelf as a boy.  It was the cover art that fascinated me and led me to the reading of Toussaint Louverture’s biography.  The book was part of a series meant for young students.  It was the compelling story of a slave who started a nation.  That nation’s history has always been as compelling.  Some would call it tragic or even comic, but there have been instances of triumph and glory.

              Laurent Dubois has retold the story in his book, Haiti The Aftershocks of History.  There are more romantic books on Haiti. The Serpent and the Rainbow comes to mind with its alternative pharmacology and rural societal persistence.  Kenneth Roberts’ novel, Lydia Bailey, has an account of the battle of Crête-à-Pierrot that is as inspiring as his description of General Dessalines is menacing.  Even Black Bagdad, by the occupying Marine officer, John H. Craige, is a romance of sorts.   Of course, a book with the title, Best Nightmare on Earth can only be about a place of chaos and fun.

             Yet such books are each only a small part of the story.  All too many of my fellow citizens only know of Haiti as the place where the earthquake took place.  One would suspect that fewer than one in a thousand realize that the country is our oldest sister republic in the new world.  The great value in Mr. Dubois’ book is that all the players and actions are there in one volume.  The book is not written in a sensationalist style.  In listening to his interviews on radio, I thought it would be.  Even so, it goes along smoothly, not that he does not show his sympathies.  Obviously, he feels Haiti has been done hard by.  Any observer would find it difficult to avoid that conclusion.

               Laurent Dubois is not new to the subject.  A previous book, Avengers of the New World is a history of the Haitian Revolution. He has written other books about the country.  His official positions include Marcelo Lotti Professor in Romance Studies and History and Director of the Center for French and Francophone Studies at Duke University.  He occasionally dabbles in other subjects.  Well, more than dabbles.

               Villains abound.  First up are the French.  On the island of Saint-Domingue, the Gauls set up the most profitable plantation system in the Western Hemisphere, if not the world.  They ran it on the backs of Africans, worked so that more had to be constantly imported.  Cost control was such that the slaves not only had to toil in the fields for the planter, they had to grow their own food as well.

               When the French Revolution broke out, the slaves took the opportunity to end their bondage in alliance with the Republicans.  When Napoleon took power he tried to reinstitute slavery.  After a valiant resistance, the Haitians merely waited until Nap’s army was debilitated and gave it a push and secured their nation.

               France was not done.  Having lost the war, they demanded an indemnity.  Talk about bad taste.  Whatever happened to vae victis?  Hungry for recognition, Haiti gave in.

               Other European powers leaned on Haiti.  Germany was stalwart in applying force to get her way.  It appears our sister republic could not count on appealing for enforcement of the Monroe Doctrine.

               Uncle Sam’s hands are not clean.  Recognition was refused until the Civil War.  We were slow to the game, but played hardball when we got up to bat.  In 1914, a warship sent a detachment ashore to seize gold from the Haitian National Bank.  American bankers who had made bad loans had the US Government enforce their contracts in the grand tradition of privatizing profits and socializing losses.  Then, Marines would occupy the country.  We left eventually, achieving little as we usually do in our occupations.

               After Duvalier fils’ exile and some sub par elections, we came back to make Haiti a better place in 1994, again.  We brought some other do gooder nations with us.  With all the help the US and the international community had provided, the last thing the country needed was an earthquake.

               Haitian governments could meet the definition of a failed state, what with almost a constitution du jour with each new chief executive.  That does not mean a failed nation.  The Haitian peasant held onto the land won from the French with tenacity unrivalled in history.  The country folks on their smallholdings fed themselves and exported coffee.  Even the vastly powerful United States left after the Haitians tired of us earlier in the 20th Century.

               Mr. Dubois is a fine writer.  Aftershocks was difficult to put down. His book is a history and not a polemic.  Still, it is hard for a reader to avoid a conclusion.  Intervention well meaning or exploitive is colonialism.  The world should leave Haiti to its own devices.

               They may not build a tourism industry, but why would they want to be our playground?  Les Haïtiens may not split the atom any time soon, but neither will the hotshots at the Kennedy School of Government.  The message to bankers should be, take your chances and don’t expect a bailout.  Maybe we should have said that to Morgan and Goldman in 2008.

               Let Haiti be Haiti.